When Rates Rise, the Opportunity Doesn’t Disappear. The Strategy Changes.
By Ashley Taylor, Licensed Real Estate Agent, Patriot Real Properties
A headline caught my attention this week:
“Home sellers may have to ‘take a hit’ as rates rise.”
The Fox Business article came after another change in the interest-rate environment and raised a legitimate concern: as borrowing becomes more expensive, affordability changes, the pool of qualified buyers can shrink, and sellers may have to adjust expectations.
But as someone who looks at real estate from both a business and investment perspective, I think there’s a bigger conversation we should be having.
A changing market doesn’t necessarily eliminate opportunity. It changes where the opportunity is—and how the deal needs to be structured.
And there’s another important distinction:
The national real estate market is not the Long Island real estate market.
What Higher Rates Actually Change
As of September 17, Freddie Mac reported the average 30-year fixed mortgage rate at 6.95%, up from 6.76% the previous week and 6.26% a year earlier.
That matters.
Higher borrowing costs affect purchasing power. Freddie Mac explains that mortgage rates directly affect affordability and that even relatively small rate differences can meaningfully change monthly payments.
But that’s only the beginning of the conversation.
When affordability changes for buyers, behavior can change for sellers.
And when seller behavior changes, investors should be paying attention.
Sellers: Don’t React to a National Headline
If you’re selling a home on Long Island, I don’t think the takeaway from this week’s headlines should be:
“Rates went up. I need to cut my price.”
It should be:
“Has anything changed in the market for my specific property?”
That’s a very different question.
What are comparable properties doing?
How much competing inventory is available?
Are buyers scheduling showings?
Are those showings producing offers?
Are comparable homes reducing their asking prices?
How long are properties taking to move?
And, importantly, what feedback are we receiving?
The market will usually give us information.
Our job is to pay attention to it.
Buyers: Your Purchasing Power Matters More Than the Headline
Buyers need to understand the other side of this too.
A higher interest rate can change what a monthly payment looks like, which means someone shopping based only on the purchase price may be looking at the wrong number.
The better conversation is with your lender:
What does this property actually cost me each month under my financing scenario?
That answer may change your price range.
It may also change the way you negotiate.
But buyers shouldn’t automatically assume rising rates mean there are no opportunities.
If some buyers step back, competition can change.
If a property has been sitting, a seller’s willingness to negotiate may change.
The asking price may not change, but other parts of a transaction potentially could.
Every deal is different.
Investors Should Be Watching Something Else
This is where the article became especially interesting to me.
As an investor, I don’t only want to know:
“Are rates higher?”
I want to know:
“What behavior are higher rates creating?”
Are properties staying on the market longer?
Are some sellers becoming more flexible?
Are there properties that didn’t make sense six months ago that deserve another look?
Are there opportunities to negotiate terms or concessions?
Are investors who depended on inexpensive financing leaving certain opportunities behind?
That’s where changing markets become interesting.
Not because higher rates are good.
They’re an additional cost of capital.
That cost has to go into the numbers.
But price is also part of the numbers.
So are rent, repairs, taxes, insurance, financing, vacancy, renovation and the amount of capital required to complete the deal.
An investor shouldn’t analyze one variable in isolation.
Don’t Make a Bad Deal Work on a Spreadsheet
There’s also a trap here.
When financing becomes more expensive, investors sometimes compensate by becoming more optimistic somewhere else.
Maybe projected rent creeps higher.
Maybe the renovation budget gets tighter.
Maybe vacancy disappears.
Maybe future appreciation suddenly becomes more important to the analysis.
That’s backwards.
When the cost of capital rises, underwriting should become more disciplined—not less.
If the deal doesn’t work with realistic assumptions, it doesn’t work.
But if a changing market creates a better acquisition opportunity, then run the numbers again.
That’s different.
Sellers May Have More Than One Lever
Price gets the headline because it’s easy to understand.
But a transaction contains more than one variable.
Depending upon the circumstances, sellers and buyers may be discussing price, property condition, timing, repairs, closing considerations or permissible concessions.
Financing options should always be discussed directly with qualified lenders, and legal or contractual questions belong with the parties’ attorneys.
The important point is that real estate negotiations don’t always consist of one number moving up or down.
Sometimes solving a deal requires understanding which variable actually matters most to the person on the other side.
This Is Why Investors Need to Understand Sellers
One of the biggest lessons I’ve learned from being involved in both real estate and investing is that numbers don’t exist in a vacuum.
There’s a person behind the property.
Why are they selling?
What problem are they trying to solve?
Is timing important?
Is certainty important?
Does the property need work?
Has it been marketed unsuccessfully?
Is the seller simply testing the market, or do they actually need to make a move?
That doesn’t mean taking advantage of somebody’s circumstances.
It means understanding that successful transactions happen when both sides can identify something that works.
A Changing Market Rewards Better Questions
I don’t know exactly what the housing market will do next, and neither does anyone else.
Rates can move.
Inventory can change.
Buyer demand can change.
That’s why I don’t think investors should build strategies around predictions.
Build them around discipline.
Know your numbers.
Know your financing.
Know your objective.
Understand the property.
Understand the local market.
And know what would have to happen for you to walk away.
The Fox Business headline says sellers may have to “take a hit.”
Maybe some will.
Others won’t.
Some buyers may step back.
Others may find an opening.
And some investors may discover that a property that didn’t make sense before suddenly deserves another look.
Opportunity doesn’t disappear when the market changes.
But the strategy has to change with it.
Ashley Taylor
Licensed Real Estate Agent
Patriot Real Properties
Patriot Real Properties
34 East Main St #346
Smithtown, NY 11787
Equal Housing Opportunity. This article is for general educational purposes and is not financial, investment, tax, legal or lending advice. Mortgage rates and market conditions change. Buyers, sellers and investors should consult appropriate licensed professionals regarding their individual circumstances.
Comments